Everyone loves a nice lawn, whether its a small patch for sitting or lounging on (surrounded by lots of pollinator-friendly planting), or a larger spot where the kids can play. A nice, lush, green lawn can feel as comfy as a favourite cushion.
One of the key ways to achieve a great lawn, along with applying a lawn feed, is to make sure you're getting air to the soil in the lawn. All the walking, sitting and lounging on your lawn can compact the soil, making it hard for the grass to grow and hard for oxygen and water to get into the roots.
Jump to:
Looking for scarifiers?
The best lawn aerators to buy in 2024
Walensee Lawn Coring Aerator, Manual
Pros: don't need to charge or plug in, inexpensive
Cons: not designed for big lawns, fewer prongs than other manual aerators
This is a heavy duty lawn aerator for particularly compacted grass. This coring aerator acts as a plug aerator, and is satisfyingly manual, which also means it's probably not quite right for you if you have a very large lawn. But for lawns that aren't too big, this one will do the job perfectly.
The two plug prongs will pull up chunks of lawn, stimulating root growth and allowing for water and oxygen to get in. The plugs are about as long as an average index finger and the aerator is very sturdy, so this should be one that is happy in your shed for a long time.
Rolling Outdoor Garden Lawn Aerator Spike Roller Gardening Tool
Pros: roller design for efficiency, don't need to charge or plug in, inexpensive
Cons: takes strength to push down
An option that's slightly easier on the back, this rolling lawn aerator has spikes that roll wherever you need them to. The spikes are 45mm long, and the length of the handle and rolling mechanism makes this a very efficient way of aerating your lawn.
You will need to assemble it yourself, but once it's all put together the roller will make the job of aerating your lawn relatively pain free and very thorough. You'll need to have strength for the push down, but that's true of all the manual aerators.
Lawn Aerator Shoes
Pros: convenient to use, neat finish, recycled construction, easy to clean
Cons: doesn't remove plugs for extra aeration
This is a lawn aerator for us. Think minimal hard work, where you're using your own weight to push down but barely any of your own strength to do it.
Attach these nifty lawn aerators to your boots and just stomp about in the garden. These are spike aerators, rather than plug aerators, so they won't bring up chunks of lawn.
The sturdy metal buckles adjust to whatever shoe size and the base is recycled plastic. The pack comes with a wrench so you can adjust the spikes and make sure you can get the shoes on simply and easily. These lawn aerator shoes are also simple to clean - you can take them off and pop them in the sink.
Electric Lawn Scarifier
Pros: electric powered, adjustable heights, grass collector bag
Cons: need to plug in
An electric lawn aerator, which also triples as a scarifier and lawn rake. This electric one has four adjustable heights from -12mm to +4mm plus a 30L grass collector box. It's not a heavy option, and should be easy to push around the garden.
One of the things that we always look out for in an electric tool is the length of the power cable and this one measures a generous 10m.
Looking for a futuristic garden tool to make your life easier? Check out the best robotic lawn mowers we've found.
Einhell GC-SC 4240-P Petrol Lawn Scarifier
Buy from Machine Mart (£370.80)
Pros: scarifies at the same time, motor powered, adjustable heights, grass collector bag
Cons: more expensive than other options, petrol powered
This petrol lawn scarifier doesn't have a lead, which makes it easy to push around the garden untethered. You can adjust the height to suit the needs of you and your lawn. The manufacturer recommends that these will work for lawns up to around 1500m2 and its 18 steel blades are there to remove moss, lawn thatch and any other weeds.
At the same time it pokes holes in the soil to make those ever-needed gaps for oxygen and water to get in. The petrol engine is 212ccs and there's a collapsable canvas grass collector too.
See our guide to the best lawn mowers to buy
Ride on mower lawn scarifier
Pros: fits almost all ride-on mowers and tractors, you can add weights to adjust intensity
Cons: more expensive than other options, only works with ride-on mowers
This is an adaptor for a ride-on mower or tractor, so if you already have a ride-on mower, this could be everything you need. It comes with a universal hitch pin, making it compatible with most models out there.
In areas of dense moss growth, you may need to add some weights to the built-in shelf to push the aerator down.
Fork aerator
Pros: don't need to charge or plug in, removable tines
Cons: not designed for big lawns
This is a classic plug aerator, measuring 111cm long. It has removable, stainless steel tines, all of which are hollow and push up old ground as you go, so there's no need to unclog them by hand.
You use the power of your foot to press down into the lawn with the plugs and you'll free up the roots and soil to let much-needed air and water in.
McGregor Lawn Aerator
Buy from Argos (£30.00)
Pros: roller design for efficiency, don't need to charge or plug in, inexpensive
Cons: takes strength to push down
This is similar to another spike lawn aerator on this list, but slightly cheaper. This roller aerator has 48 spikes and works using a simple manual mechanism: helped by your own strength! It doesn't need output energy, so you could call it one of the most energy efficient of the list.
It's 148cm high and you can easily take it apart, which is great for storage. The spikes are 2.5cm which is more than enough of a hole to puncture into your lawn.
Buyer's guide
How do lawn aerators work?
A grassy lawn can get impacted easily from all the activity on top of it which makes it hard to get oxygen to the soil and grass roots. Step forward the lawn aerator. Ultimately a way of putting holes into your lawn, the holes promote root growth as well as enable oxygen into the layers of soil. It also frees up the lawn to allow more water in.
What's best, a spike or plug aerator?
There are two different types of lawn aerators. A spike aerator works by literally pushing spikes into the lawn and thereby leaving holes. A plug aerator pulls out a plug of soil to create holes. A plug aerator works very hard at reducing soil impaction, and is better for heavy clay soils. The spike aerators are better for sandy or loamy soils.
When to aerate your lawn
When to do this depends a little on the grass you have. Ryegrass is the most common grass in the UK and the US, and this grass should ideally be aerated in the spring or autumn.
Some experts recommend aerating your lawn every six weeks, which is definitely not how often we aerate our lawns, but may be the secret to your perfect spongy and healthy green sward.
For scarifiers, see our list of the top models we recommend for simple lawn maintenance: The best lawn scarifiers to keep your grass healthy
